| 
 | 
 
 
 | 
K-12 Issues in the NSDL
Room: Federal B
 
Marcia Mardis 
 
Content, description, presentation, and user retention are all issues with unique application to K-12. Members of K-12 related projects and other interested parties will meet to discuss how the NSDL can best serve K-12 educators and learners. Project information and venues for collaboration will be explored. 
 
 
Notes - K-12 Issues in the NSDL
 
In Attendance 
- Marcia Mardis, Michigan Teacher Network
 - Soo-Young Lee, TERC
 - Sarita Nair, EDC
 - Susan Van Gundy, CI
 - Ed Geary, DLESE/DWEL
 - Vivianlee Ward, National Health Museum
 - Steve Moore, Center for Image Processing in Education
 - Karen Cariani, WGBH
 - Ted Sicker, WGBH
 - Nancy Lane, PREL (Ethnomathematics DL)
 - Judy Spicer, ENC
 - Carolee Barber, ENC
 - Maggie Hellie, science teacher, Panama City FL
 - Joni Falk, TERC
 - Chris Klaus, Argonne National Labs, AVC
 - Gary Olson, East Iowa Community College
 - Siva Kumari, Rice University
 - Dean Zollman, Kansas State, Pathway Project
 - Bruce Mason, Oklahoma University, ComPADRE
 - Ellen Hoffman, Eastern Michigan University
 - Joanne Silverstein, Information Institute of Syracuse, AskNSDL, -SUN
 - Kurt Feicheier, Exploratorium
 - Francis Molina, AAAS, Project 2061
 - Chris Quintana, University of Michigan, IdeaKeeper
 - Bruce Caron, New Media Studio
 - Bryan Aivazian, DWEL
 - Raj Pandya, UCAR/DLESE
 - Paddy (David) Patterson, Marine Biological Laboratory
 - Denise Blumenthal, WGBH
 - Quentin Briggs, ICON
 - Lee Zia, NSF
 - Ted Hodapp, NSF
  
 
Discussion 
 
Ellen H. 
Let's not forget about the other groups within K-12 other than MS.  
 
Maggie H. 
The focus should be on elementary since that's where the mindset has started. 
 
Sarita N. 
We should not approach users in isolation; they are all connected. 
 
Chris K. 
Is this going to be the only focus? 
 
Susan VG 
This is a targeted phase, to go to elementary would be too big of a drop; the goal is to build something extensible 
 
Joanne S. 
We should look at this as an opportunity to use MS as guinea pigs and develop data gathering and evaluation methods 
 
Ellen H. 
MS is like an exhibit in a museum; it's not all of the contents, but an exhibit. 
 
Bryan A.  
Much interdisciplinary work happens in MS 
Science, technical stretch 
 
Siva 
Many projects are prepackaged to run only for a year 
 
Bruce Caron 
(sorry didn't catch this one Bruce--fill it in if you can) 
 
Dean Z. 
Middle school is the least defined area can span grades 5-10 What about focusing on teacher education as the broadest spectrum 
 
Joni F.  
Look at it as a lens on MS--it's not the collection, it's what you do with it. 
 
Ted S.  
This seems like a paradigm shift, but it's just working with what exists in the NSDL 
 
Susan VG 
Taking what we have and putting a view on it 
 
Maggie H. 
I often use the same content but present it different ways at different levels (e.g., properties of ice cream) 
 
Ed G. 
MS can be a catalyst and help NSDL identify areas of weakness 
 
Chris K. 
Not all of the needs are NSDL funded efforts-how will we work with other NSF projects? 
 
Bryan A. 
We need to develop a set of exemplars to show teachers why they want to play in this game 
- understand teacher needs
 - create a statement of value
 - make them feel that this is a place they want to be
 - remember teacher training
  
 
Gary O. 
Many teachers are teaching out of area and rely on science standards to tell them what they need to be doing 
 
Siva 
What was the framework for this decision? We need some background 
 
Ellen H. 
What else should be happening in projects that are not focused on MS? 
 
Chris K. 
What about old collections? 
 
Susan VG 
Two sources of information: K-12 email list and Susan VG 
 
Joni F. 
What are we sacrificing for MS? Is the rest of K-12 out now? 
 
Ellen H. 
Don't forget about one library, many portals 
 
Chris K. 
How about this strawman: 
- Tools
 - PD
 - Help with producing media
 - Community development
 - Email lists
  
 
Francis M. 
What about an effort to engage standards 
 
Nancy 
(didn't get this one Nancy--please fill it in) 
 
Maggie H. 
What's the role of inquiry in all of this? 
 
Vivianlee W. 
State standards can't be forgotten; students have the achieve according too standards 
 
Quentin 
Technology standards should not be forgotten and included with curriculum standards. We need to engage zealots at each state level. 
 
Steve M 
(Missed this one Steve--fill it in) 
 
Maggie H. 
How are we going to make peace between inquiry and state standards? Are we going to make a choice? 
 
Joni F. 
We need to collect the best practices of the NSDL projects 
 
Steve M. 
Standards correlation is very important 
 
Denise B. 
Context context context We need to help teachers discover what is now undiscoverable and scaffold their use. 
 
Lee Z. 
Special emphasis on MS--not to the exclusion of other communities. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Comments
Please enter any comments in the following format. 
- (commenters' initials) - month/day [comment date]
 - comment
  
 
 
 | 
 
 
 |