Printing Introduction to Metadata
Introduction to Metadata
Vivian Lee Ward, National Health Museum
Diane Hillman, Cornell University
Judy Ridgway, ENC / The Ohio State University
Marcia Zeng, Kent State University
John Marquis, University of Southern California
Links
List of controlled vocabularies
List of Current Operational and Proposed Metadata Standards
Recorder: Judy Spicer, ENC/The Ohio State University
The following questions will be answered: What is metadata and why is it valuable? How do the various standards (Dublin Core, IEEE LOM, SCORM, and DOI for example) relate to one another? What metadata standard will best describe your collection? What are the challenges and hurdles to avoid and overcome? What is the relationship between metadata and searching your collection? What is the relationship between metadata and your catalog record display? What is OAI and what are the minimal metadata elements that make your collection harvestable in a meaningful way by NSDL.org?
Notes - Introduction to Metadata
Questions and answers for Introduction to Metadata
- 1 Q There were two schemas talked about--IEEE LOM and Dublin Core (DC). What are the differences? Is there any way to describe the differences between these two schemas that may lead a project to decide which one to use?
Diane Hillmann (DH): The two organizations have agreements. The basics of DC are expressed in IEEE LOM. DC is simpler, somewhat flatter in its abstract model which is where the main distinction lies. Difference is specialization. IEEE LOM is really talking about learning object while DC is more generalizeable. LOM offers much for learning object metadata. Dublin Core is lingua franca. To learn more see the Introduction to Metadata by Pricilla Caplan.
- 2 Q When will enhancements to harvesting be available?
DH--Soon after meeting, within a month.
- 3 Q Vocabularies feedback. Is there any kind of a master feedback that�s going to come to people so that we can start to work with something that�s more common?
Judy Ridgway (JR): The vocabularies (you refer to) were for the metadata repository not a taxonomy. The vocabularies that you sent me had to do with evaluations to assess the metadata repository, not to recommend a taxonomy to anybody.
Questioner: It may be time to stop being so abstract with metadata�(missed rest)
DH: We often do not know what taxonomies are being used. DC has the ability to explain what taxonomy or vocabulary you�re using so that other people can know what�s going on. DC is working on a registration that will help with identification of specific taxonomy. So if you�re using some other taxonomy, you need to tell us what it is.
- 4 Q: Since NSDL is using Dublin Core, can you state a simple compelling reason why one would want to use LOM.
DH: If it is important to have information at that level to describe your objects�use it. Decisions are up to creator. We can help you figure out how to give it to us so that we can spread it to other people.
Why Did ENC choose LOM over DC?
JR: It has specific aspects that we use such as the educational description , information about the learner, that doesn�t fit in DC.
DH: Yes, so you would want to use it if you had an overriding pedagogical reason Consider your objects--LOM is very complicated and hard to find out info.
- 5 Q I wonder about strategies when the learning objects are dynamically assembled.
DH: Difficult question. I know that�s one of the issues that the IEEE LOM committee is trying to address, so you should get involved with them.
- 6 Q We have a picture and an overlay. We don�t want user to only get the meaningless overlay. Is there anyway NSDL can take the Requires field and use that?
DH: We�ll pass on the information, including the required fields, but we can�t provide any functionality based on that. Part of the project planning process maybe to only expose certain resources now and some you will expose later. You still want to share data with us, just maybe not all of it yet.
- 7 Q If somebody could just paint a picture. On the metadata primer on the site there are examples of a record, what does the final record look like?
DH: That�s what OAI does. It will be a DC record in an OAI wrapper.
- 8 Q The thing that I am most afraid of is taxonomy issue. There is good advice and direction on the DC. For the new projects, would you (recommend a taxonomy), is there a sort of priorities that you�d suggest we look at taxonomies in? Where to start?
DH: You have to figure out your taxonomy. The key is not that you use the same taxonomy as anybody else but that you explain what taxonomy you are using. Eventually, this thing will scale up enough and there will be services that make connections within those taxonomies based on a semantic understanding of what they are.
- 9 Q Do you prefer that we not invent taxonomies?
Diane: If you want to, and it�s a big business, then do it properly. Look into how you need to do it so that others can reuse it. Make sure you�re going to expose it and maintain it so that others can use it. You can expose several vocabularies. So I would encourage you if you�re doing something very specific then you expose several vocabularies. First thing is to pick a taxonomy. Expose the taxonomy you are using. We will make semantic connections. Key is exposing and maintaining use. Inventing a taxonomy is a big business. You will hate yourself in the morning if do not think it through.
Marcia Zeng (MZ): We just had the DC conference where we talked about such things. Any metadata schema has controlled vocabulary and Best Practice guides with suggestions about what vocabulary to use. We see that right now most people just extract the terms they need (from an existing taxonomy) and tell her (Diane) what you are using. (Explained Green�s Fields thesaurus use.) If you use IEEE LOM then there�s a taxon field that lets you specify the general subject, although it�s different from the subject field. Create a thesaurus for a project IEEE LOM has taxon field that is very general that is different from the subject field�DC has same
Diane: The key is not that you use the same taxonomy as anybody else but that you explain what taxonomy you are using. Eventually, this thing will scale up enough and there will be services that make connections within those taxonomies based on a semantic understanding of what they are. First thing is to pick a taxonomy and tell everybody what you�re using.
- 10 Q We�re working with a project from NASA about drawing annotations from images. When you foresee implementation of annotations?
DH: I don�t have an answer to that, it�s one of the things we know we must implement but we don�t have a timetable for it. It is very much on the table.
- 11 Q Video collection metadata?
DH: There are a number of metadata schemas for video work with mpeg technical and granularity issues. There is application profiles where you can use parts of one scheme and another not either or.
JR: Isn�t Carnegie Mellon using a schema for digital video? (nobody�s sure what they�re using)
DH: There is actually something called application profiles where you can use parts of one schema and parts of another; there�s not a lot of guidance about how to do that, but you should look into some of that work as well.
MZ: There are special media examples related to metadata markup languages so you can index into the frames.
Recorded 10/14/03
Judy Spicer and Faith Anne Myers
ENC
Comments
Please enter any comments in the following format.
- (commenters' initials) - month/day [comment date]
- comment